Analysis of the initiative to sanction vicarious violence through sentient beings
The local representative of Citizen Movement, Luisa Ledesma, has presented a legislative proposal of notable social and legal relevance. Its initiative seeks to criminally sanction a specific form of gender violence known as vicarious violence, which, in this case, is exercised through mistreatment or threats towards pets. The presentation of this proposal took place during a parliamentary session, with the main objective of modifying the Penal Code of Mexico City and other related legal systems.
The proposed reform establishes a custodial sentence ranging between two and six years in prison for any individual who commits violence using sentient beings to whom the affected woman has a verifiable emotional link. This legislative measure represents a significant advance in the recognition of the complex dynamics of power and control that characterize sexist violence, expanding the spectrum of protection beyond traditional figures.
Rationale and context of the legislative proposal
Vicarious violence is conceptualized as one of the cruelest and most calculated expressions of aggression, given that its objective is not direct physical harm to the woman, but rather a deep emotional blow directed at what she values most. Traditionally, this form of psychological violence has been exercised through sons and daughters. However, empirical evidence and case reports indicate a change in the methodology of aggressors, who now instrumentalize sentient beings as an effective mechanism to inflict pain and exercise control.
Legislator Ledesma bases her initiative on contemporary social reality, highlighting the proliferation of multispecies families. In Mexico City, thousands of women cohabit with dogs, cats and other animals that transcend the category of property to become emotional support and integral members of the family nucleus. This relationship of affection and mutual dependence is precisely what makes them a vulnerable target for perpetrators of violence. Phrases such as “if you leave, the dog stays”, “if you report it you will never see it again” or “I am going to hurt it so you understand” are verbal manifestations of a strategy of coercion and threat that seeks to break the woman’s will through the suffering of an innocent being.
Legal and social implications of the reform
The cardinal importance of this legal initiative lies in its ability to correct an evident legal vacuum. Although this form of aggression frequently occurs in the domestic environment, its explicit recognition in the regulatory framework is insufficient or nonexistent. The reform proposes, therefore, an explicit legal recognition that actions such as threatening, mistreating or illegally removing a sentient being can constitute, per se, an act of vicarious violence.
The representative argues that this discussion transcends the merely legal to delve into the human, social and deeply emotional. When a woman decides to leave an abusive relationship, her primary need is to find institutional support and security guarantees, not to face new and sophisticated forms of threats. Aggressors take advantage of this legal loophole; They are aware of the strength of the emotional bond between a woman and her pet and they manipulate that affection as another resource to perpetuate the cycle of violence. Mexico City, with this initiative, would take a firm step towards comprehensive protection, recognizing that violence directed at a pet is, in essence, indirect violence towards women.
In her conclusions, the legislator established a crucial connection: protecting animals is also protecting women, and vice versa. The specialized literature on criminology and domestic violence frequently indicates that animal abuse within the home functions as a predictive indicator of more serious interpersonal violence. Ignoring these warning signs carries a substantial risk to the safety of all members of the family group, human and non-human.
Share this analysis on your social networks to make this important initiative visible and explore more content related to advances in legislation on gender violence.
