Exemptions for ultra-Orthodox in Israel: a political decision with military consequences
Israel’s Parliament (Knesset) passed two laws that, in practice, prevent ultra-Orthodox men from being recruited into the army. The measure, promoted by Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu, seeks to ensure the support of religious parties ahead of the October 27 elections.
One of the rules freezes the arrests of those who evade arrest. The other enshrines the study of the Torah as a “founding value” of the State, which provides a legal basis to oppose Supreme Court rulings that consider these exemptions illegal.
Rejection inside and outside the Government
The chief of the General Staff, Eyal Zamir, described the measures as “incompatible” with the needs of the Army. In a letter to Netanyahu and the defense minister, he wrote:
“It is inconceivable that the military system under my command, which demands unprecedented sacrifice from its personnel, would be party to granting mass exemptions from prosecution.”
Opposition leader Yair Lapid said the law is “an absolute desecration of the name of God” and “spits in the face” of soldiers.
Historical context and numbers
The exemptions have existed since Israel’s founding in 1948, but the Supreme Court declared them illegal. The debate resurfaces as the Army faces personnel shortages after almost three years of armed conflicts in Gaza, Lebanon and Iran.
Every year, about 13,000 ultra-Orthodox young people turn 18, but less than 10% enlist, according to a parliamentary committee. The prime minister seeks the support of the haredis for the next elections; Analysts point out that he is trying to get them to negotiate only with him after the elections.
For ultra-Orthodox legislator Moshe Gafni, the approval is historic. He stated:
“For thousands of years, the study of the Torah was the force that preserved the Jewish people. This law will be a compass for the values of the State.”
The decision generates tensions even within the ruling party and opens a debate about the balance between tradition and defense needs.




