Australia is not shrinking: the anti-networking law for minors still stands
It seems that the Australian government has decided that its mission is to be the strict digital parent that no one asked for, but that everyone (or at least some) is going to have. Even though a rights group with a name that sounds like a low-budget spy movie – the Digital Freedom Project – filed a constitutional lawsuit against them, those in Canberra didn’t bat an eyelid. The ban that will prevent Australian minors under 16 years of age from having accounts on certain social platforms, the one that is a worldwide pioneer, will come into force on December 10 as if nothing had happened. A true legislative “sorry, not sorry.”
Communications Minister Anika Wells basically put on her “We’re Not Moving” t-shirt and testified before Parliament with a determination that reminded us of that friend who says she’s never going to talk to her ex again. “We will not allow ourselves to be intimidated by legal challenges. We will not allow ourselves to be intimidated by large technology companies,” he stated. Millennial translation: the read receipt is activated and they read the message, but they don’t plan to respond.
Libertarian resistance and the parental dilemma
On the other side of the trench is John Ruddick, the president of the Digital Freedom Project and, to add more flavor to the matter, a state legislator for the minority Libertarian Party. His argument is every rebellious teenager’s wet dream: this is a direct attack on his freedom of political communication. Ruddick drops the pearl that “parental supervision of online activity is today the primary parental responsibility.” In other words, according to him, delegating this job to the government and its “unelected bureaucrats” is like asking a stranger to scold your child. A bit uncomfortable, really.
The court case is being handled by Sydney lawyers – Pryor, Tzannes and Wallis Solicitors – on behalf of two 15-year-olds who, supposedly, see their right to see memes and make stories seriously threatened. Sam Palmer, the group’s spokesman, couldn’t even say whether they will seek a court order to stop the law before it takes effect. A level of organization that makes us wonder if this is a legal strategy or a university project group that left everything until the last minute.
Technology companies enter the game (obligatory)
While the adults fight, in the real (or rather, digital) world, Meta is already in collateral damage mode. Last week, the tech giant began sending warnings to thousands of accounts of Australian children suspected of being under 16 years old. The message is simple and stark: download your digital memories and delete your Facebook, Instagram and Threads account before 10-D. It’s the digital equivalent of when your parents tell you “tidy up your room or I throw everything in the trash.”
The government has been clear: Meta, along with Snapchat, TikTok, Not to be dramatic, but that’s enough money to buy all the avocados in an entire city.
And if the Australian drama were not enough, on the other side of the map Malaysia is already taking notes. His Communications Minister, Fahmi Fadzil, announced that his cabinet approved plans to implement a similar ban from 2026. Its justification is to protect young people from the dangers of the internet, such as cyberbullying, scams and sexual exploitation. He even mentioned that they are studying the Australian approach and the possibility of using electronic verifications with identity cards or passports. Basically, they want to make logging in as complicated as getting a visa.
All this legislative chaos leaves us with an existential question: are we facing the era of digital overprotection or is it a necessary movement in an increasingly savage online world? Only time (and the next protest memes) will tell.
Do you think this law is the solution or an excess? Share this note and tell us what you think on your networks. And if you are interested in the future of the internet, be sure to explore more content about technology and society on our website.
